About cockroach traps
This does reveal a significant weakness of roach traps, however – they kill only the roaches that get in them. Baiting and trapping may be a good way to control the population of, say, bears, but it’s much less effective with roaches. The reason for that is that roaches leave huge numbers of eggs in their nests and these eggs are more or less independent from their parents once they hatch. So, no matter how many adult roaches you trap and kill, as long as there are surviving eggs in the roach nests, you’ll be facing a new wave of roaches pretty soon.
This doesn’t make roach traps unusable, however – they do have their fair share of applications:
- Detecting the presence of roaches. If your neighbor’s home was recently invaded by roaches or if you’ve recently seen a roach or two wandering around, a roach trap can help you assess whether you do have an actual roach problem or it was indeed just a couple of wandering roaches.
- Monitoring the presence of roaches. If you’ve recently gotten rid of an extensive roach infestation, roach traps are the best way to make sure that the buggers are truly dealt with. If any cockroaches are still alive after an extermination then you’ll want to know about it as soon as possible.
- Preventing future roach infestations. The way roaches invade our homes is by sending roaches everywhere to “investigate” and eventually settling down in places that offered a favorable environment. By killing off any roach that enters your home from the outside before it could lay its eggs you can essentially make sure that you’ll never have a roach problem in your home.
- Dealing with light or medium roach infestations. While not intended as “extermination tools”, good roach traps can deal with lighter roach problems. Even though they kill only the adult roaches that can get to the traps and not affect the nests, if the roach traps keep killing every new roach that leaves the nest before it has had a chance to lay eggs, then they can deal with the whole problem. Still, their effectiveness shouldn’t be overestimated. A lot of homeowners try to use roach traps for serious roach problems and reach the conclusion that roach traps simply don’t work. That’s how questions such as “Do roach traps work?” start circulating around. They do work, but it’s important to know how and for what they work.
What are the differences between roach traps and roach baits? Don’t roach traps use baits?
This can be a little misleading – roach traps often use baits to attract roaches in them, yes, but the term “roach bait” refers to another device. Roach baits work in a similar and yet different way than roach traps – they attract roaches with their delicious baits, but they actually contain toxic poison instead of glue. Once the roach consumes the poison from the bait it’s free to keep walking around and doesn’t die then and there. This is a good thing as it gives the roach time to get back to its nest and potentially poison and wipe out the entire nest at once.
It’s relatively easy for roaches to get infected from one another – most pesticides used in roach baits are transmitted even just from contact. Add to that the fact that young and small roaches have the habit of eating the excrements of adult roaches until they become adults themselves and it becomes even easier to wipe out an entire nest with even just a single poisoned roach.
What other alternatives to roach traps are there?
Aside from roach baits, there are also the traditional roach sprays. Most of them work on a similar principle to roach bats – you spray a location with the pesticide, the roaches pass over it, they get infected with the pesticide just by touch it, and they either die then and there or they reach their nest and they infect it too. A sprayed spot with a typical roach spray can remain toxic to roaches for months, depending on the amount of its active ingredient.
There are also room roach sprays, which are intended to just be sprayed in the air, toward living roaches. These sprays are meant for people who are so terrified of roaches that they not only can’t wait for the traps, baits or other sprays to do their job, but they can’t even kill a roach with a shoe. By spraying a roach with such a spray you can effectively kill it on the spot, yes, but you’re not doing anything to affect the roach’s nest, plus you are literally spraying pesticides in the air you’re breathing.
Of course, there are a lot of natural “roach repellents” out there, as well as a lot of DIY suggestions for natural repellents that are circling the internet. We wouldn’t recommend most of them as they simply don’t work, but there are some commercial spray repellents that utilize natural essential oils that can be effective.
Are cockroach traps safe for children and pets?
Most roach traps are toxin-free and don’t bring much of a risk for poisoning your child or your pet. Even when do contain some toxins, they are usually in such minuscule amounts that they can hardly do any serious harm to them. The real dangers lie in the trap itself – a lot of traps are made out of cardboard, but others are made out of plastic. Additionally, a lot of them are made out of easy to disassemble smaller parts. So, if your child or pet finds such a roach trap and breaks it down, they can easily consume some of the smaller plastic parts and experience problems with that. In that sense, roach traps present a similar danger to small toys or toys with small plastic parts.
Another danger of roach traps is that while they aren’t usually toxic themselves, they do serve as a cockroach killing zone and – at least until you empty them / throw them away – as a sort of cockroach graveyard. And that is about as bad as it sounds. The whole idea of getting rid of roaches is that they bring a ton of possible diseases with them. So, letting your child play with something that contains a couple of dozen of dead roaches in it really isn’t something you probably want.
With all this in mind, the roach traps that are usually deemed as “safe for pets” or “safe for children” are the ones that:
- Are not made of plastic and/or don’t contain any small pieces that can be broken off of them;
- Are small/flat enough so that they can easily be hidden below furniture or behind kitchen appliances, where your kids and pets can’t reach.
What is the bait of a roach trap?
Roach trap baits can be pretty much anything edible. Breadcrumbs, pieces of fruits and vegetables, anything that a roach would eat. Sugar and sweets are the most tempting thing for roaches, with chocolate being very close to the top of the list. This is one thing in which roaches and humans are not that different.
Roach trap buying guide
Some are meant to be big in order to trap as many roaches as possible, but that makes them harder to fit underneath furniture or behind kitchen appliances. Others are intentionally really small as to be easily placed anywhere you want, but that usually demotes them to just detection and monitoring devices as they can hardly deal with a full-blown roach infestation.
Some are pet-safe and kid-safe in that they are harder to reach or harder to disassemble. Others intentionally come without bait so that you can choose what bait you want to put on them. Others don’t even use bait at all but are meant to attract cockroaches through pheromones or to not attract them at all and simply need to be placed in key locations that cockroaches traverse frequently.
All these variations have their positives and negatives with none of them being better than the rest in 100% of the possible situations. So, to choose and buy a cockroach trap that will do as good of a job as possible, the first step is to recognize what trap you need for your home. Some of the key questions to ask yourself are:
- Do I have children or pets that I need to keep off of the roach traps? As we mentioned above, some roach traps are safer for pets and kids than others, so you should always consider them first if you have either kids or pets.
- How bad is my roach problem? Depending on your situation you might need smaller “detection” roach traps that will serve as a way to determine the level of the infestation you’re dealing with.Not only that but be prepared to take even more drastic measures soon if even that trap proves ineffective. As we said, roach traps are effective up to a point.
If you know that there are more cockroaches that you’re not seeing they you shouldn’t bother with smaller traps at all – get the biggest roach trap with the most killing potential you can find.
- How much money am I ready to spend on traps? Depending on how bad your problem is you might need some more extensive measures soon, whether roach sprays, roach contact killers or even have to call exterminators. With that in mind, it’s understandable if you don’t want to spruce a ton of money on mere card box glue traps. Fortunately, most cockroach traps aren’t really that expensive, but it is still something to keep in mind.
- How big do I need the roach traps to be? Roach traps can vary a lot in their size. That has an effect not only on the number of pests they can kill but also on their size. There are over 4000 species of cockroaches across the globe with some being as small as big ants, while others being as huge as small mice. It’s good to have at least some idea of what you’ll be dealing with, since some roach traps can be too small for some roaches, while bigger traps can be impractical for others.
- How many roach traps do I need? Some packs of roach traps contain 2 or 3 traps. Others can contain more than a hundred. It obviously doesn’t make sense to buy more traps that you expect to use, but it’s even more annoying to buy a few and have to buy more on the very next day. Assess carefully how many traps you’re going to need so that you can avoid both of those scenarios.
- Do I want them to come with roach bait or not? Most roach traps come with their own roach baits inside of them, but a lot of customers prefer otherwise. That’s because more often than not the baits inside the traps are not as effective as something that you can put in them yourself. There are a lot of things that cockroaches are happy to eat – they didn’t survive for as long as they have by being picky eaters. But if you want your roach trap to be truly effective you can maximize its chances by putting the most alluring bat possible in it – chocolate!
Once you’ve answered these question you’ll be in a much better position to make the right choice. After that, what you need is the research and the information for buying not just the type of cockroach trap that best suits your needs, but one that’s of a high-quality as well. After all, there are good roach house traps and bad ones, there are great roach motel traps, and there are awful ones, and so on.
Unfortunately, doing all the research necessary to distinguish the good ones from the bad ones is neither quick nor pleasant to do. Reading customer reviews is as unreliable for roach traps as it is for any other product niche. In fact, it’s more unreliable than most. Because the effectiveness of a roach trap depends not just on the item itself but on how and where it’s used, it’s very common for users to think that they’ve bought a crappy product when in reality they’ve just used it in a crappy way.
Under literally almost every product online you can read multiple customer reviews that state that “some of the traps they used from the same worked and others didn’t, so, clearly, not all traps of said are good”, when it’s clear that some of the traps were placed in good places, while others were placed where roaches didn’t pass through.
Lack of context, subjectivity, accidental and anecdotal problems, lack of know-how, and so on, are just a few of the many problems that can make a customer review unreliable. Professional industry reviews are also there, of course, and they can be of great use for getting extra information about the product. They too can sometimes be biased, however, so it’s a good idea to read them with that in mind.
Once you’re done with all the research too (of which, hopefully, we’ve saved you some), it’s time to make a decision – you know what you need and you know which the high-quality products are. If you’re still hesitating between several products, considering the roach trap’s brand is also not a bad idea. As with other product niches, some brands are known to offer a much higher quality than others. Some of the brands we’d recommend include: Black Flag, Harris, Alazco, Becase, Bell Trapper, Victor, New Trapro, Roach Busters, Greener Mindset, and others.
Bonus tip: If you’re deciding between two or three different roach traps it’s sometimes a good idea to buy all of them (provided that you won’t end up with 300+ roach traps in your possession that you don’t know what to do with).
Using different types of roach traps at the same time makes it more likely that at least one of them will work effectively enough, plus it will give you an even better idea of which type was the best.
Other useful information about cockroach traps
DYI roach traps – how to do it and should you do it?
Being such simple devices, roach traps are actually not complicated to make. You don’t need a degree in either chemistry nor engineering to make a roach trap. All you need is a piece of cardboard, plastic, or anything else, a nice, powerful and scentless glue, and a delicious bait. So, basically, the glue is the only tricky component. It’s important that it’s scentless so it doesn’t repel the roaches, but also that it’s still powerful enough to hold them still once they get on top of it. If you’re not sure on which of the glues available in your local hardware store can do the best job, you can just make several roach traps using different glues and see which works best.
That being said, however, we need to point out that we don’t recommend you to do this. Commercial roach traps are fairly cheap and they are guaranteed to be at least as good of a job as anything you can make yourself or better (provided that you buy an actually good roach trap). So, there really is little reason for you to make your own roach traps, regardless of how easy it is. This is important not because we want you to purchase commercial products, but because roach infestations are not a joke. You may have seen just a couple of roaches last week and nothing more, but in the meantime, you can have dozens or hundreds of roaches in your walls and crawlspace. Delaying with even a day can mean the difference between having to deal with the infestation with a couple of traps and one spray can and having to call an exterminator. And as easy as it is to make a roach trap yourself, there’s always the risk of using the wrong glue and effectively losing several days due to that.
What else can you do to protect your home from roaches aside from using traps, sprays and other protection methods?
The best way of protecting your home from roaches has always been to just keep it clean. Roaches eat leftover food left unattended, be it on the kitchen counter or minuscule bits that have fallen on the floor. They can even lead human or pet hair, skin and excrements that we may have left on the floor of the bathroom or elsewhere. So, if you want to never have to deal with roaches, make sure that they don’t want to pay you a visit – clean your home regularly and extensively and you’ll most likely never have to deal with roaches.
Cleanliness is even more important while you’re using roach traps. The idea of the roach trap is to attract roaches to itself with its bait. But if the corners of your kitchen are covered with unintentional “baits” anyway, the roaches will be attracted to them just as much as they’ll be attracted to the trap.
Roach trap usage
And this more or less exhausts the things that you need to do with the traps once you’ve placed them if there aren’t any roaches present – change the traps every once in a while when they’ve expired.
If you do have roaches and the traps are more than just a prevention method, then there’s more to be done. First of all, you need to make sure that you’re placing the traps as well as possible. We already touched upon that but it bears repeating – roach traps may work by attracting cockroaches to themselves but they don’t really have that great of a reach. After all, they are not the only thing in your home that’s “alluring” to cockroaches. So, it’s of the utmost importance that you are placing your roach traps where roaches go through as this way you can be sure that they won’t miss the bait.
Additionally, you’ll also need to change the roach traps much more frequently if they are actively capturing roaches. You can’t just leave a trap with a couple of dozen of dead roaches in it and expect it to keep working at full capacity. Not to mention that these many dead roaches are generally something you want to get out of your home as soon as possible.
And that’s the gist of it – make sure that the traps are new and fresh, as well as that they are where they are supposed to be, and you should be fine.
Roach traps may not be the best way to exterminate a full-blown roach infestation, but they are great at prevention, detection, monitoring, and control of cockroaches and other insects.
When used correctly a good cockroach trap will clearly show you whether you have a cockroach problem or not, how intensive it is exactly, as well as start dealing with it and keeping it under control, giving you time to decide whether more drastic measures are needed or not. Add to all that the fact that most roach traps contain no pesticides and are a healthier alternative to roach sprays and contact killers, and their inclusion in your homeowner’s arsenal becomes a no-brainer.
So, to wrap things up, here are our Top 3 best roach trap suggestions once again:
The Black Flag Roach Motel comes in a pack of 12 boxes with 2 traps in each box for a total of 24 roach killers. Small and discreet, these boxes can be placed almost anywhere in your home as long as you know that there’s a cockroach activity there. They are eco-friendly and non-toxic, they have a very strong and irresistible lure, as well as a powerful glue. Being rather small, they are not intended for bigger pests, but they work wonderfully for most roaches and other small insects.
The Alazco Glue Traps are very simple and yet plastic boards with powerful glue on them. 5.25″x 7.75″ in size, they come without bait so you’ll need to put your own bait on them. With chocolate, sugar and other sweets doing a great job at attracting cockroaches, however, that’s not much of a trouble. The Alazco traps are easy to place anywhere in your home and their glue is more than strong enough to capture and kill any insect that makes the mistake of walking over them.
The Becase Cockroach House Traps are a great example of why house traps are so effective roach control tools. They contain both an alluring bait as well as a powerful glue. Additionally, the roof feature is there to keep the glue clean of dust particles, effectively prolonging its life, as well as to keep the nastiness of your sight. One downside is that the roof makes the traps both harder to set up, as well as harder to fit in some places that are often frequented by cockroaches.